TL;DR
Compare total compensation, included services, investment costs, provider duties and service quality using identical plan data, then document and repeat the review.
A benchmark compares a service package, not a single price
A useful benchmark compares the total cost of a defined service package for plans with similar facts. The lowest quote may leave important work, charges and responsibilities outside the price.
A Utah employer may receive one bundled price from a recordkeeper, separate invoices from several providers and investment costs deducted inside the plan's funds. Those numbers do not become comparable just because they share a spreadsheet.
The real task is to determine what the plan receives, what it pays in total, who receives the money and who remains responsible for each job. Private Advisory's workplace retirement consulting addresses these connected questions through plan design, operational support, employee support, investment-lineup oversight, vendor management and benchmarking. Private Advisory serves employers from offices in Lehi, Utah, and Redmond, Washington.
For Utah employers, the fee-review framework cited here comes from federal ERISA guidance; these sources do not supply a Utah-specific fee threshold. The Employee Retirement Income Security Act, commonly called ERISA, sets federal standards for most private-sector retirement plans.
The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) explains that ERISA does not set a permissible fee level. Plan fiduciaries must decide whether fees are reasonable in light of the services provided and continue monitoring them. Fiduciary status can arise from discretionary plan management or administration, authority or control over plan assets, or providing investment advice for a fee under the applicable rules. It depends on the functions performed, not just a title. Fees are only one part of the decision, alongside service quality and participants' needs, according to the guide on meeting fiduciary responsibilities.
Start by fixing the comparison date and plan facts:
- Total plan assets as of the same date
- Number of eligible employees
- Number of participants with account balances
- Annual contribution and distribution activity
- Plan design and employer contribution formula
- Loan, hardship withdrawal and other optional features
- Number and type of investment options
- Expected participant meetings, communications and individual support
- Reports, committee meetings and compliance support required
- Payroll systems and other data connections involved
Federal guidance recommends giving prospective providers complete and identical information, including participant count and plan assets as of a specified date. Without that common input, one provider may price today's work while another assumes a smaller or simpler plan.
Which cost categories belong in the comparison?
A complete comparison separates recurring plan costs, investment expenses, participant charges and one-time costs.
The federal retirement plan fee guide groups expenses into plan administration fees, investment fees and individual service fees. The hosted 401(k) fee disclosure tool also identifies investment-product fees, administration expenses, conversion charges and termination fees.
Use those sources to organize proposals, not to produce a single approved price:
| Cost or service area | What to identify | Questions to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| Recordkeeping | Account tracking, transactions, website, statements and reports | Is pricing based on assets, participants, accounts or a fixed amount? |
| Plan administration | Accounting, legal, trustee and other day-to-day administration services not already captured in the recordkeeping row | Which services are included, and which trigger a separate charge? |
| Investments | Expense ratios and other investment-level charges | Is the cost deducted from investment returns? Does it help pay another provider? |
| Advice and oversight | Investment review, committee support and provider monitoring | What written work and meeting schedule are included? |
| Participant services | Education, call-center help, meetings and individual guidance | How often are services available, and who delivers them? |
| Individual transactions | Loans, distributions and other participant requests | Who pays each charge: the employer, plan or affected participant? |
| Conversion | Data transfer, setup and other transition work | Is the amount fixed, estimated or dependent on data quality? |
| Termination | Contract exit and provider-termination charges | What charges or notice periods apply if the plan moves? |
Administration costs may be paid directly or covered partly through investment fees. A proposal with a small recordkeeping invoice may therefore carry meaningful costs elsewhere.
How should direct and indirect compensation be compared?
Trace every payment to its source and recipient, including money that never appears on an employer invoice.
Direct compensation is payment received directly from the covered plan. This discussion concerns ERISA-covered 401(k) plans subject to these disclosure rules; the regulation excludes certain other retirement arrangements from its definition of a covered plan. Indirect compensation comes from a source other than the covered plan, the plan sponsor, the covered service provider or an affiliate, subject to the rule's distinction for certain subcontractor compensation. A covered service provider is a provider that contracts with the plan and reasonably expects at least $1,000 in direct or indirect compensation for the services the rule lists, whether that work is performed, or that compensation received, by the provider itself, an affiliate or a subcontractor. In plain terms, an affiliate is a company related to the provider, and a subcontractor is a firm the provider hires to perform part of the work; the regulation defines both terms precisely. "Indirect" describes the payment source; it does not mean the charge is hidden.
These definitions apply for purposes of the regulation's service-provider disclosure rules, 29 CFR 2550.408b-2(c)(1) (text retrieved November 17, 2026). They are not general definitions of everything a plan or an employer pays, and they are not accounting categories for the employer's total cost.
Amounts the employer pays and is not reimbursed for from plan assets fall outside both regulatory categories. If the plan reimburses the employer for an amount, ask the provider how it has categorized and disclosed that amount. Track employer-funded amounts separately while including them in the broader review of every cost tied to the arrangement. Federal fee disclosure guidance explains that covered service providers must disclose specified services and compensation so the responsible plan fiduciary can assess reasonableness and identify possible conflicts. The responsible plan fiduciary is the person with authority to cause the plan to enter into, extend or renew that provider's contract.
For each payment, record:
- The recipient
- The payer or source
- The amount or calculation method
- Whether the payment changes as plan assets or participant counts change
- The service connected to the payment
- Whether the provider shares compensation with another party
- Where the charge appears in contracts, disclosures or investment materials
A blank or vague entry is not zero. It is a request for clearer information.
For background on Private Advisory, readers can review the Private Advisory Form CRS (May 2026) and access the firm's Form ADV and Part 2 brochure filings through IAPD. The retail Form CRS is background firm information, not a substitute for plan-specific agreements or required compensation disclosures.
Why does the way fees are allocated matter?
Fee allocation matters because two plans with the same total cost can divide that cost very differently among the employer and participants.
An employer may pay some expenses directly. Other expenses may be paid from plan assets. Participant-level charges may be allocated per capita, meaning a flat dollar amount per account, or pro rata, meaning in proportion to each account balance. Investment expenses are commonly deducted inside the investment option.
That allocation affects who bears the cost. For example, a flat annual recordkeeping charge takes the same dollar amount from a new employee's small account and a long-tenured employee's large account. A charge based on assets produces a different result. Neither method can be judged from the total alone.
Ask each provider to show the annual dollar effect on at least three sample account sizes. This is cost allocation, not an investment-return projection. It lets the committee see whether a low employer invoice depends on higher participant charges.
How do bundled and unbundled arrangements become comparable?
Break every arrangement into functions before comparing its total price.
A bundled arrangement places several services under one provider and one stated fee. An unbundled arrangement uses separate providers and charges for functions such as recordkeeping, administration and advice. The federal fee guide explains both structures and says fees should be evaluated against all covered services.
For each function, assign one of four labels:
- Included in the quoted fee
- Funded through indirect compensation
- Charged separately
- Not provided
Then name the party responsible for doing the work. A lower bundled quote may omit a service found in another proposal. A higher unbundled total may contain work the committee does not need. The labels reveal both situations without treating either delivery model as automatically preferable.
Private Advisory's service scope can help frame an employer's questions. Its workplace retirement work includes coordination among payroll providers, recordkeepers and administrators, along with investment-lineup oversight and vendor management. The precise duties, compensation and allocation of responsibility still need to be stated in the engagement documents.
What service quality belongs beside the fee numbers?
Service quality belongs in the benchmark when it is defined in terms the committee can check.
Federal guidance tells employers to consider quality as well as cost when plan assets pay provider fees. A less expensive provider that cannot perform the necessary work may be as problematic as paying too much.
Useful measures include:
- Payroll files accepted accurately and on schedule
- Contribution or eligibility errors and time to correct them
- Participant call response and resolution times
- Delivery of required reports and notices
- Attendance and preparation for committee meetings
- Website availability and transaction processing
- Escalation procedures for urgent plan issues
- Participant complaints and how they were resolved
- Data-security standards and available audit reports
- Completion of contracted education or individual-support sessions
Choose measures that match the written scope. A service-level score should not reward a provider for an attractive feature that the plan neither requested nor uses.
How should investment expenses be reviewed?
Investment expenses should be compared within the role each option serves in the plan's lineup.
An expense ratio is the annual operating cost of an investment, shown as a percentage of assets. It is deducted within the investment rather than billed as a separate employer invoice. Federal guidance identifies investment management as a major component of plan costs and notes that higher investment fees do not necessarily mean better performance.
The committee should examine:
- The expense ratio for each option
- The type and purpose of the investment
- Whether a lower-cost share class or similar vehicle is available to the plan
- Whether the investment pays compensation connected to another service
- Whether replacing the option would change recordkeeping or other pricing
- Whether participants have enough information to compare their choices
Do not add investment expenses to a provider proposal without checking whether that proposal already credits some investment-related compensation against another charge. Otherwise, the comparison may count the same economic cost twice.
What does a worked fee comparison look like?
A defensible decision starts by correcting the proposals, not by declaring the cheaper quote the winner.
Consider this hypothetical example. A Utah employer receives two proposals for the same 401(k) plan.
Proposal A shows a lower recordkeeping price. Its investment materials disclose compensation that helps pay for administration, participant transactions carry separate charges, and moving away from the provider would create a termination cost.
Proposal B shows a higher recordkeeping price. It includes several participant transactions and scheduled committee support, but conversion work is estimated separately.
The committee should not invent missing dollar amounts or rank the proposals yet. It should:
- Send both providers the same participant, asset and plan-design data.
- Place each cost and service in the same categories.
- Apply the rule's direct and indirect compensation definitions, then list amounts the employer pays and is not reimbursed for from plan assets in a separate column; where the plan reimburses the employer, ask the provider how it has categorized and disclosed that amount.
- Mark omitted services and estimated charges.
- Show who pays each fee.
- Ask each provider to correct or complete its disclosure.
- Compare the revised total cost with the services the plan actually needs.
- Record why the selected arrangement is reasonable for that scope.
The result is not proof that the selected provider has the lowest market price. It is a documented comparison of relevant choices using consistent information.
How should an employer document a prudent process?
A useful file shows what the committee knew, what it compared and why it acted.
Federal fiduciary guidance says prudence focuses on the decision-making process. It recommends surveying providers with the same requirements and information, understanding contracts, obtaining regular service updates, reviewing arrangements at renewal and documenting the process. Ongoing monitoring should cover actual fees, reports, provider performance and participant complaints.
Keep these materials together:
- Current plan document and amendments
- Service agreements
- Provider fee and compensation disclosures
- Investment expense information
- Participant fee disclosures
- Plan data used for the comparison, with its effective date
- Written request for information or proposal
- Completed comparison worksheet
- Notes about missing or corrected information
- Committee meeting materials and minutes
- Decision memo stating the reasons for selection or retention
- Schedule for the next review
- Reports used to check actual fees and delivered services
Minutes need not contain a transcript. They should identify the materials reviewed, the issues discussed, any conflicts considered and the basis for the decision.
When should the benchmark be repeated?
Repeat the review at planned intervals and when the arrangement changes in a way that could affect cost or service.
Possible triggers include:
- Contract renewal
- A material change in compensation
- Rapid growth in plan assets or participant accounts
- A merger, acquisition or payroll change
- A change in plan design
- Persistent service failures
- A provider acquisition or platform conversion
- New investment options or share classes
- A large increase in complaints
- A proposed recordkeeper or administrator change
Federal service-provider guidance recommends establishing a formal review process at specific times, checking actual charges and confirming that services are delivered as agreed.
A benchmark becomes stale when the plan, contract or compensation changes. The review date matters as much as the comparison date.
What responsibility remains with the employer?
Hiring outside providers does not end the employer's responsibility to understand the plan and oversee the arrangement.
The IRS tells plan sponsors that they remain responsible for keeping the plan compliant and should know what their service agreements do and do not cover. Its plan sponsor guidance also stresses the need to understand plan documents, administrative tasks and information flows.
Fee benchmarking is different from hiring an adviser. Benchmarking tests the cost and scope of the whole arrangement. Adviser selection focuses on one provider's services, compensation, responsibilities and qualifications. An adviser may help organize a provider review, but the employer should still know who makes each decision and who monitors each provider.
Before signing or renewing an agreement, put those roles in writing. Titles are not enough.
What should a Utah employer do next?
A Utah employer should gather the plan's contracts, disclosures, investment expense data and recent invoices before asking any provider for a new price.
Normalize the current arrangement first. That baseline will show whether a new proposal changes only the price or also shifts work, compensation and responsibility. Give every provider the same plan data, require written answers and set a date for the committee's decision.
Employers that want a second read on current scope, provider responsibilities and compensation before requesting new pricing can contact Private Advisory. Any proposed duties and fees should be confirmed in the applicable written agreement.
The important comparison is the complete arrangement the committee can explain, monitor and defend.
FAQ
How can I tell whether my company's 401(k) fees are reasonable?
Compare total compensation with the services, provider responsibilities and relevant benchmarks, using the plan-specific agreement and compensation disclosures. Benchmarking and vendor management are part of Private Advisory's workplace retirement consulting. A lower quoted advisory fee alone does not establish a better arrangement.
What documents do I need for a 401(k) fee-benchmarking review?
Collect provider agreements, compensation disclosures, invoices, investment expense information, plan asset and participant data, and a list of services actually delivered. Show employer-paid and plan-paid amounts separately. Private Advisory's benchmarking and vendor-management services can be discussed using that common set of records; the agreed scope determines the review.
Does the lowest 401(k) proposal satisfy the employer's duty?
Not by price alone. The employer must consider the services, total compensation, conflicts and service quality, then document the basis for its decision.
What is a 408(b)(2) disclosure?
A 408(b)(2) disclosure gives the responsible plan fiduciary — the person who can cause the plan to enter into, extend or renew the contract — information about covered services and the compensation connected with a covered service arrangement. The controlling definitions turn on the payment's source and apply for purposes of the service-provider disclosure rules in 29 CFR 2550.408b-2(c)(1) (text retrieved November 17, 2026), as explained in the compensation section above.
Can I benchmark my 401(k) plan without changing providers?
Yes. A review can identify questions about cost or service without committing the employer to a replacement. Compare the current agreement and delivered services with relevant alternatives, then document whether to retain, renegotiate or replace the arrangement. Confirm the scope and cost of any outside benchmarking engagement before commissioning it.
Should employer-paid and participant-paid fees be combined?
Include both when comparing the arrangement's total cost, but show each payer separately. Amounts the employer pays and is not reimbursed for from plan assets fall outside both regulatory categories. If the plan reimburses the employer for an amount, ask the provider how it has categorized and disclosed that amount.
Does hiring a 401(k) adviser transfer all responsibility from the employer?
No. The employer retains responsibility for prudently selecting and monitoring providers. The written agreement should state any duties assigned to an adviser or another provider.
About Private Advisory
Private Advisory is a wealth management firm serving founders, business owners, executives and families across the western United States. The team combines financial planning and investment management to help clients navigate business sales, equity compensation, retirement and the transfer of wealth across generations. Its work connects investment decisions with cash-flow needs and family priorities, while coordinating with clients' independent tax and legal professionals. Private Advisory also offers family office services for eligible clients and workplace retirement consulting for employers.
This is not tax or legal advice. Consult your own tax and legal professionals.
By Quinton Bean
This material is for educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Consult qualified professionals regarding your circumstances.
